On the same $400 bag, what do you keep at Rebag vs Fashionphile?

Two consignment leftovers, same verb. Rebag Help “What is Rebag’s commission structure?” (dated 21 Sep 2023, live-fetched 28 Aug 2026, HTTP 200): commission rates “are the fees that you pay,” typically 15–25% of net sales, as low as 8%, actual take on the quote. The Commission Rates chart named in that article is not in the HTML and has no Zendesk attachments — this pair will not invent a SKU row. If the quote prints 15%, house $60.00 keep $340.00. If it prints 25%, house $100.00 keep $300.00. Fashionphile US Seller Terms (Last Revised April 10, 2026, HTTP 200 this fetch): they take 30% of sale price up to US $3,000. $400 is under that cliff, so house $120.00 keep $280.00. Percents are official; subtraction is ours. Buyout has no published percent on either rail.

Why is this not “Rebag takes half of Fashionphile”?

15% is not half of 30% as a settled ticket. Rebag’s 15–25% is a typical band with the real percent on Clair, because Help names a category chart and then does not ship the table. Fashionphile’s 30% is a published cliff on sale-price proceeds for every $400 consignment under $3,000. Honest house cuts on this sticker, if the Rebag quote prints the band, are $60–$100 vs $120 — not $60 vs $280, and not $340 vs $120. Do not average 15, 25, and 30 into a fake 23% luxury rate.

Do you print a Rebag category chart or a Fashionphile buyout percent?

No. Rebag Help tells you to “take a look at our Commission Rates chart” broken out by category and net sales price — live HTML on 28 Aug 2026 is one paragraph, empty attachments, no table. 2023 press that printed 35% under $750 or 8% on $50k watches is not this pair. Fashionphile Sell-with-us (HTTP 200) emails a buyout offer in 7–10 business days; Seller Terms never print a buyout percent of resale, so this page will not invent one. The H1 “bag” is the $400 sticker, not a forged Chanel cell.

Is this a 50-state sales-tax engine?

No. Rebag discounts Help applies the take to net sales price (selling price minus discounts). Fashionphile Seller Terms put the 30%/15% take on sale-price proceeds. Empty tax on both rails is the official base, not a state table we skipped. Confirm the sold / net-sales dollar in your accounts.

Same $400 bag. Typical band vs 30% take.

Q: How is this different from Fashionphile vs The RealReal and from Rebag fees explained?

Fashionphile vs The RealReal mills a 30% house take against a clothing 60% keep of Net Selling Price on the same $400 ($280 vs $240). This card never mills RealStyle’s 20–70% pay language. Rebag fees explained is the decoder: three machines (Consign / Trade / Buyout), Wallet 3% early / +10% spend / Premium Payouts 9 months, Rebag+ up to 5% capped, pull-back 3% min $50. This card is the pair: Rebag typical-band take → $340–$300 keep vs Fashionphile 30% cliff → $280 keep. Do not quote this page as $280 vs $240, and do not treat it as a buyout-percent mill or a SKU chart.

Two houses take the piece. Both subtract a take. Only one of them published the percent in a contract. Live Rebag Help What is Rebag’s commission structure? (article dated 21 Sep 2023, HTTP 200 this fetch) still calls commission the fees that you pay — typically 15–25% of net sales, as low as 8%, actual rate on the quote (Rebag fees explained). The Commission Rates chart that sentence points at is not in the HTML. If a $400 net sale prints 15%, leftover $340.00. If it prints 25%, leftover $300.00. Live US Seller Terms & Conditions at fashionphile.com (Last Revised April 10, 2026, HTTP 200 this fetch) still takes 30% of the sale price up to US $3,000 (Fashionphile fees explained) — leftover $280.00 when that $400 is a consignment sale they shot and listed. Identity of this card: Rebag typical-band take (chart missing) vs Fashionphile published 30% cliff. It is not Fashionphile vs The RealReal (30% take vs clothing 60% keep — $280 / $240). It is not the three-machine Rebag decoder. It does not mint a buyout percent. It is not a 50-state tax table.

Independent — not affiliated with Rebag, Fashionphile, Neiman Marcus, or The RealReal. Live fetch 28 Aug 2026 (America/Chicago). Rebag commission Help HTTP 200: “Commission rates, which are the fees that you pay” — as low as 8%; most items typically 15–25%; “Take a look at our Commission Rates chart” for category × net sales — one paragraph, empty Zendesk attachments, no table; actual rates “communicated individually for each quoted item.” Discounts Help HTTP 200: take sits on net sales price (selling price minus discounts). Selling with Rebag HTTP 200: three methods — Consign, Trade, Buyout; Rebag+ “up to 5% higher payouts on every sale.” Fashionphile US Seller Terms HTTP 200: “FASHIONPHILE will take as fees” 30% of sale price up to US $3,000 and 15% of the portion above; 90-day Initial Consignment Term; 25-day discount right; Wallet cash-out (wire $50; store credit / NM gift card +10%). Consignment marketing page HTTP 200 says the leftover out loud: “Our base fee is only 30% of the selling price (you keep 70%).” Sell-with-us HTTP 200: buyout is an emailed offer in 7–10 business days; payout estimated 2–4 days after receipt and authentication — no published buyout percent of resale. Help “What are FASHIONPHILE’s consignment fees?” returned HTTP 200 as an empty Salesforce shell; the indexed body of that URL still matches the Shopify 30%/15% take. Gaps this pair will not fill: Rebag’s named Commission Rates chart is a sentence, not a parseable grid — this card will not assign 15% to handbags or 8% to watches; 2023 launch coverage that printed 35% under $750 stays off this pair; Fashionphile’s return period is not printed as N days — payout waits until that unnamed window plus cleared payment plus shipped; buyout is a quote on both rails; tax is already outside Rebag net sales and Fashionphile sale-price proceeds — not a 50-state tax engine. Confirm inside your accounts. Planning model — not tax, legal, or accounting advice. No affiliate IDs.

Same $400 card (typical band vs 30% cliff)

Default: $400 as Rebag net sales and as Fashionphile consignment sale price. Rebag is the official typical-band floor 15% only if the quote prints 15% → leftover $340.00. Switch the slider to 25% for the official typical ceiling → leftover $300.00. Fashionphile is under the $3,000 cliff: they take 30% → leftover $280.00. Buyout stays off unless you paste an offer into a different tool — this pair will not mint a percent. 8% is the official “as low as,” labeled; Help does not assign 8% to a $400 bag.

Same dollar (Rebag net sales / Fashionphile sale price)

Rebag quoted take % (paste from Clair — not a SKU row)

Rebag leftover = net sales minus the quoted take. 15 and 25 are the official typical band, not a category assignment. Fashionphile leftover = sale price minus 30% of the first $3,000 minus 15% of the rest. Under $3,000 the 15% never fires. Planning math only — not a payout screenshot. USD only. Buyout is a quote, not a slider here.

—

Rebag consignment (quoted take of net sales)

—

Fashionphile consignment (30% take ≤ $3k)

—

Gap (Rebag keep − FP keep)

—

House remainders (Rebag take / FP take)

—

The unique unit: two consign houses, same verb, different publication

Both rails authenticated the piece. Rebag’s commission Help, opened 28 Aug 2026 (HTTP 200, article dated 21 Sep 2023 — still the live body):

“Commission rates, which are the fees that you pay, are based on your item's listing price and category. You’ll pay less for in-demand, high-value pieces (as low as 8%) and more for lower-value items. Most items will typically fall in the 15-25% range.”

Fees that you pay. Take. On $400, if the quote prints 15%, house $60.00, leftover $340.00. If it prints 25%, house $100.00, leftover $300.00. Help then says: “Take a look at our Commission Rates chart for an indicative overview of rates broken out by category and net sales price.” Live HTML: one paragraph. Empty attachments. No <table>. This pair will not invent the missing grid.

Fashionphile’s US Seller Terms, opened the same day (HTTP 200, Last Revised April 10, 2026):

“FASHIONPHILE will take as fees the following percentages from the proceeds of the sale of your Consignment Items: 30% of the sale price up to a sale price of US $3,000; and 15% of the sale price for the portion of a sale price in excess of US $3,000.”

Will take. $400 never crosses the $3,000 line, so the 15% remainder is idle. House $120.00, leftover $280.00. The consignment marketing page says the same machine backwards — “base fee is only 30% of the selling price (you keep 70%)” — keep-language for the identical 30% take, not a second fee card.

Call both numbers “commission” and you have still not left the take column. That is the job of this pair. Fashionphile vs The RealReal exists because RealStyle pays 20–70% of Net Selling Price — a keep, not a take. This pair never mills that 60% clothing cell. “Rebag keeps 15%” flips Help. “Fashionphile keeps 30%” flips Seller Terms. “15 is half of 30, so Rebag is half the house” treats a quoted band as if it were the April 10 cliff. Honest house tickets on this $400 row, if Clair prints the typical band, are $60–$100 vs $120 — not $60 vs $280, and not $340 vs $120.

Same $400 bag — sticker dollar, not a forged SKU chart

Line	Rebag consignment (Help 21 Sep 2023 body, live 28 Aug 2026)	Fashionphile consignment (Seller Terms, 10 Apr 2026)
What the % is	They take a quoted commission of net sales. Typical 15–25%. As low as 8%. Actual rate on Clair. Chart named, not in HTML.	They take 30% of sale price at or under $3,000. Dollars above $3,000 drop to 15%. Marketing page: “you keep 70%” is the leftover of that 30%, not a second schedule.
Fee base	Net sales price = selling price minus discounts. Discounts Help: payout range already bakes typical markdowns. Empty tax is official, not a skipped state table.	Sale-price proceeds. Terms do not mill tax into the 30%. Empty tax is official, not a skipped state table.
Who does the listing work	They authenticate, price, list, and sell. You send the piece (prepaid FedEx from a staffed Ship Center). Quote is generated before you ship.	They authenticate, price, list, and sell. You send the piece (label / pick-up / studio). 90-day Initial Consignment Term, then auto-extends until sold.
Clock	Buyer-return pending 15–25 days. Once status is Sold, Wallet within the following 15 business days. Then 15 days more to skip the 3% early cash-out (decoder territory).	Payment after (i) the return period has elapsed with no return and (ii) the purchaser’s payment has cleared and the item has shipped. Return period is not printed as N days — gap disclosed. Then Wallet.
Authentication / pull-back	Bundled into the quoted take on a completed sale. Want-it-back Help: 3% of listing, min $50 max $300, plus $50 ship, typically ~90 days — decoder territory, not this leftover.	Folded into the 30% on a completed sale. Seller Terms bill $75 (or $125 Birkin/Kelly) only to recover an inauthentic or early-terminated piece during the 90-day Initial Consignment Term — not a line on this leftover.
Off this card	Buyout (quoted purchase, no published %). Trade (US-only toward a cart). Wallet 3% early / +10% spend / Premium Payouts. Rebag+ up to 5% capped. Those live on the decoder.	Buyout (quoted purchase, no published %). Wire $50 / store-credit +10%. Refresh table. UK £3,000 twin. Decoder pages, not this leftover.

Rebag (re-opened 28 Aug 2026): Help: What is Rebag’s commission structure? (HTTP 200 — fees you pay; typically 15–25%; as low as 8%; chart named, not present), Help: discounts & promotions (HTTP 200 — take on net sales price), Selling with Rebag (HTTP 200 — Consign / Trade / Buyout). Fashionphile (re-opened 28 Aug 2026): US Seller Terms & Conditions (HTTP 200 — Last Revised April 10, 2026 — 30% / 15% of US $3,000), Consignment (HTTP 200 — “base fee is only 30% … you keep 70%”), Sell To Us (HTTP 200 — buyout offer, no published %), Help: consignment fees (HTTP 200 Salesforce shell; indexed copy matches Shopify 30%/15%). Stacks: Rebag seller fees explained, Fashionphile seller fees explained. Inverted-verb pair (not this card): Fashionphile vs The RealReal. Hub: /seller-fees/.

1. Do not invert either take. Do not treat a band as a cliff.

On $400, USD, empty extras, consignment — not buyout, not Trade:

Rebag typical-floor take (only if quote prints 15%) = 15% × $400 = $60.00 → leftover $340.00.
Rebag typical-ceiling take (only if quote prints 25%) = 25% × $400 = $100.00 → leftover $300.00.
Fashionphile take = 30% × $400 = $120.00 → leftover $280.00.
Keep gap at the floor = $340.00 − $280.00 = $60.00. Keep gap at the ceiling = $300.00 − $280.00 = $20.00. Neither dollar is a coupon. Different legal bases (net sales vs sale-price proceeds), different clocks (15 business days after Sold vs unnamed return window), different markdown rights, and Rebag’s percent is not even a published cell.
House gap at the floor = $120.00 − $60.00 = $60.00 the other way. Same $60, inverted leftover.

$340 is not “Rebag is cheaper than Vestiaire self-list.” Vestiaire’s US self-list leftover on this sticker is also $340, and you photographed that listing. This page does not mill Vestiaire’s US 12% + 3% self-list, does not mill a 65% Vestiaire consign keep, and does not mill RealStyle’s 60% clothing keep. If you came here from a keep-percent worksheet, stop and open Fashionphile vs The RealReal.

2. $400 sits in a typical band and under a published cliff — not a decoder dump

$400 is inside Rebag Help’s “most items will typically fall in the 15–25% range.” That sentence is a band, not a Chanel flap cell. The quote is the rate. This pair defaults the slider to 15% because that is the official typical-band floor, then labels 25% as the official typical-band ceiling, and labels 8% as the official as-low-as — not because Help assigned any of those three numbers to this bag.

$400 sits entirely under Fashionphile’s $3,000 line, so the house takes 30% of the whole sticker. The 15% remainder never starts. A $5,000 Fashionphile sale is the decoder’s two-step arithmetic ($900 on the first $3,000 + $300 on the rest = $1,200 house / $3,800 keep). This pair exposes that preset only to prove the cliff; the identity of the card is still $400.

The H1 says bag because both houses’ public SKU is a luxury bag and the user-facing sticker is $400. Rebag Help then says rates vary by listing price and category — and prints no category table. Fashionphile’s cliff does not care whether the $400 is a small leather good or a flap; under $3,000 the take is 30%. Typical-band take of net sales is the Rebag unit we can source without inventing a grid.

3. Buyout is a quote. It is not a third percent on this pair.

Selling with Rebag (HTTP 200, 28 Aug 2026) is a three-lane page: Consign, Trade, and Buyout. Buyout Help: Wallet deposit within 30 business days after inspections. The offer is the keep. No page we opened prints “buyout = X% of later resale.”

Fashionphile Sell-with-us (HTTP 200, 28 Aug 2026) emails a buyout dollar in 7–10 business days, ships a complimentary label or schedules free UPS pick-up, and estimates payout 2–4 days after the piece is in-house and authenticated. Seller Terms: the quote dies at 30 days; cash moves only after receipt, assessment, authentication, and your yes on the final Buyout Offer (including any inspection rewrite).

Folding two emailed purchases into a 15–25% vs 30% leftover is how a roundup mints a third column this pair does not have. Rebag Wallet 3% early cash-out, +10% Spending Bonus, Premium Payouts, Rebag+, Trade 5% vs 10% incentive disagreement — decoder territory (Rebag fees explained). Fashionphile Wallet $50 wire, store-credit +10%, Refresh percents of original purchase, UK £3,000 twin, $75 / $125 Authentication Fee — decoder territory (Fashionphile fees explained). This pair’s default leftover is consignment typical-band $340–$300 vs cliff $280.

4. Clocks and markdowns — why $20 or $60 is not a coupon

Rebag pays into the Wallet within 15 business days after the listing moves from Pending Sale to Sold. Buyer-return Help puts a 15–25 day pending window in front of that Sold flag. Fashionphile waits out an unnamed return window with no return, then cleared payment, then shipped — then Wallet. March at Rebag can still read Pending Sale while March at Fashionphile is still inside that unnamed window. Faster is not cheaper. Two contracts, two clocks.

Rebag’s take already sits on net sales (selling price minus discounts); Help says the pre-approved payout range bakes typical markdowns, and they notify you if a later cut would break the range. Fashionphile reserves the right to discount after 25 days; the 30% then sits on the marked-down sale price. This card mills empty extras. Confirm the sold / net-sales dollar in your accounts before you treat $340 vs $280 as a settled wire.

Worked $400 — and the cliff checks

Sticker	Rebag keep (typical-band take, if quote prints it)	Fashionphile keep (take schedule)
$400 @ 15% — this card floor	15% take $60 → keep $340.00	30% take $120 → keep $280.00
$400 @ 25% — this card ceiling	25% take $100 → keep $300.00	30% take $120 → keep $280.00
$400 @ 8% (as-low-as, labeled)	8% take $32 → keep $368.00. Help does not assign 8% to a $400 bag.	30% take $120 → keep $280.00
$800 @ 15%	15% take $120 → keep $680.00	30% take $240 → keep $560.00
$3,000 @ 15% (FP cliff)	15% take $450 → keep $2,550.00	30% take $900 → keep $2,100.00
$5,000 @ 15%	15% take $750 → keep $4,250.00	30% of $3,000 = $900 + 15% of $2,000 = $300 → house $1,200 / keep $3,800.00

Percents are official. Subtraction is ours. Last checked 28 Aug 2026. $5,000 only exists here to show the $3,000 line fire. The identity is $400 → $340–$300 vs $280. Rebag 15% and 25% rows are labeled “if the quote prints it.” They are not a SKU assignment.

When $340 beats $280 — and when you left the unit

$400 consignment, quote prints 15%, empty extras: $340.00 vs $280.00.
$400 consignment, quote prints 25%: $300.00 vs $280.00. Same labor. The band closed most of the gap without changing houses.
Quote prints 8%: labeled as-low-as. Help reserves 8% for in-demand high-value pieces. A $400 bag is unlikely to print it. Do not treat $368 as the default leftover.
You are comparing buyout: you left the unit. Paste the emailed offer. Do not invent a resale percent for either house.
You are comparing a Rebag category row: you left the unit. Help named a chart and then left it off the readable page. Typical band is the sourced rail.
You are comparing The RealReal clothing keep: you left the unit. That pair is $280 vs $240 on Fashionphile vs The RealReal.
Fiction: “Rebag keeps 15%,” “Fashionphile keeps 30%,” averaging 15 and 30 into one closet rate, quoting this pair as $280 vs $240, quoting it as Vestiaire $340 vs $260 vs $240, milling tax into either %, treating Wallet extras as the default leftover, filling a buyout percent from a blog, or pasting 2023 press 35%-under-$750 onto this $400.

Drop this $400 sticker on the hub worksheet

Open the profit calculator on /seller-fees/ (site home: realratecalc.com).
Rebag $400, quote shows 15: referral 15, processing 0, flat 0. That 15 is the house take. Do not type 85. If Clair printed 25, type 25.
Fashionphile $400: referral 30, processing 0, flat 0. Do not type 70 into a take field.
COGS is what you paid for the bag. Leftover on this pair is platform take-home before sourcing.
Match a Wallet line. Help moves. Rebag’s live percent lives on your quote, not on a public category table.

Rebag stack: Rebag fees explained. Fashionphile stack: Fashionphile fees explained. Inverted-verb pair (30% take vs 60% keep): Fashionphile vs The RealReal. Hub: seller-fees index.

FAQ

On the same $400 bag, what do you keep — Rebag or Fashionphile?

Rebag leftover is a band: $340.00 if the quote prints the typical-floor 15% take of $400 net sales, $300.00 if it prints the typical-ceiling 25%. The Commission Rates chart is not in the Help HTML — those two percents are the published typical range, not a category assignment. Fashionphile leftover is $280.00 because $400 is under the $3,000 cliff and the house takes 30% of sale price. Last checked 28 Aug 2026. Confirm in each account. Buyout is not this leftover.

Why is 15% vs 30% not “Rebag costs half as much”?

Both percents are takes, but they are not the same kind of publication. Rebag’s 15–25% is a typical band with the real number on the quote. Fashionphile’s 30% is a published cliff for every consignment at or under $3,000. Honest house remainder on that $400 row, if the quote prints the band, is $60–$100 vs $120, not $60 vs $280.

How is this different from Fashionphile vs The RealReal?

That card is a 30% house take against a clothing 60% keep of NSP ($280 / $240). This card is two takes on the same $400: Rebag typical band → $340–$300 vs Fashionphile 30% cliff → $280. RealStyle’s “we pay” language is not on this page. Do not quote this pair as $280 vs $240.

How is this different from Rebag fees explained?

That page is the decoder: three machines (Consign / Trade / Buyout), Wallet 3% early / +10% spend / Premium Payouts, Rebag+ up to 5% capped, pull-back 3% min $50, the 5% vs 10% Trade-incentive disagreement. This page is the pair against Fashionphile’s published 30% cliff. Typical-band leftover is the worked Rebag rail. Buyout, Trade, and Wallet extras stay on the decoder.

Do you print a Rebag SKU chart or a Fashionphile buyout percent?

No. Help names a Commission Rates chart broken out by category and net sales price, then ships one paragraph with empty attachments. Sell-with-us emails an offer; Seller Terms never print a buyout percent of resale. This pair will not invent the missing grid or the missing buyout percent. The H1 “bag” is the $400 sticker.

Is this a 50-state tax engine?

No. Rebag’s take sits on net sales. Fashionphile’s 30% is of sale-price proceeds, not sale price plus tax. Empty tax is the official base on both rails.

Where are the full stacks?

Rebag seller fees explained (quoted take, typically 15–25% / as low as 8%; buyout is a quote; Trade is US-only). Fashionphile seller fees explained (30%/15% of $3,000; buyout is a quote; Wallet extras). Inverted-verb pair: Fashionphile vs The RealReal. Hub: /seller-fees/. Home: realratecalc.com.

Open the profit calculator Rebag fees explained Fashionphile fees explained Fashionphile vs The RealReal Seller-fee hub

Seller-fee hub · Rebag fees explained · Fashionphile fees explained · Fashionphile vs The RealReal · realratecalc.com